Saturday, April 17, 2021

The Timelessness of Dated Rhetoric

For Gore and Amiri

The term “post-truth” implies
    That it was ever told.
Yes it was waved over
    Like a censer above,
Implied in the strongest,
    Least uncertain terms,
But there was always a line
    And whoever it was
On the hot mic at the time 
    Knew not to cross it.

Now it is dealt freely
    Because it has no power
To compel belief any more
    -- That’s a thing for gunpoint,
The thing done in war you may not
    Be especially proud of,
But at least you can say
    You survived,
-- Although that too is a lie,
    As you’d know 
If you were able to think 
   And feel anymore.

The mists came so slowly,
    The word of it so easy
To dismiss, as it came from the others
    With strange colors and accents,
It was fun, in fact, to bully the weak,
    To go along with the blitzkrieg
That never seemed so wrong
    As long as it was funny
And you didn’t take it seriously,
    But in the end
They cared more about you than
    You did yourself,
And it got a bit old when the bombs
    You kept dropping never worked
And the puny ones stood with arms upraised
    To stare you in the eyes
And ask “why aren’t you human?”
    But, by then your dreams
Of vengeance had turned to self-defense
    And the opportunity to change
Became the threat you had to gird
    Your loins to rise above.

The whole thing went down
    As if overnight,
The books were erased,
    The rules deformed,
The visible world became
    A spurious plank
To base your still-burning sense
    Of moral outrage upon;
So justice became the duty
    To silence the truth,
Love became the taking away
    Of human privileges
From those who believed
    That everyone was free,
Everyone was worthy, that there was no
    Need to kill or judge or shame.
And soon that was all there was,
    As if it has always been this way,
Pure barbarism with the furious assurance
    Of a scorned God.

And I, in order to speak with you,
    Must utter those truisms
Of genocide and terror you prefer,
    As if you had nothing to do
With them, as if they are benign
    Because your heart is pure.
Whatever I say, allowed or not,
    Doesn’t wake you,
As I would pray, from your stupor,
    It only stirs up hatred
For what I represent: a question,
    A presumption of freedom,
An uncomfortable feeling that love and care
    Are actually knives and guns.

Is there nothing I can do
    But nod my head
And applaud your clever wiles
    To be able to cut to the front of the line
To rape and be killed? Oh I’m so happy
    For you, the lessons
You will learn, so hard! So very important!
    You are blessed in the highest
Chambers of God for taking such
    A difficult road!
And even this I can’t say,
    For you’d remind me how
You don’t believe in woo-woo
    Bullshit like that anyway.

So I must leave you now
    To firebomb the villages
While I tend to a few
    Fruit trees.
I will give you what you ask for,
    If never what you need,
The shirt off my back, your weight
    On my shoulder …
What happens at this point
    Is finally not my fault.